Monday, November 29th 2004
Berkeley Hypocrisy
UPDATE: A letter by Mrs. De Witt regarding this issue (Via Res Ipsa Loquitur).
Hot on the heels of today’s anti-Israel protest, we’re getting word of a developing controversy.
The city is Berkeley is trying its best to prevent an anti-terrorism rally (props to Clarity & Resolve).
Susanne Kalter De Witt is unable to comprehend the position being taken by Berkeley City Hall officials in California regarding her request to hold a Rally Against Global Terrorism on January 16, 2005. She explains that her permit application went unanswered, prompting her to contact the appropriate city officials.
She explains that she was told her “Rally Against Global Terrorism” might make the Women in Black, MECA (Middle East Childrens’ Alliance), and other anti-Israel groups counter-demonstrate.
City officials add they fear security demands may exceed their abilities, citing a scheduled speaking engagement for then Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu who was unable to speak in Berkeley because of a near riot a number of years ago. The City of Berkeley’s concern was ‘’security,” they said in an effort to explain their apprehensions.
Kalter, a Holocaust survivor, is accusing city officials of a discriminatory and uneven policy practice, citing examples of other groups that were granted permits to hold rallies in Martin Luther King Jr. Park.
Contrast this with the following event (by way of Wizbang)
Hedy Epstein is an 80-year-old Holocaust survivor who tours the country giving speeches at universities and to nonprofit groups. Her scheduled appearance at UC Berkeley’s Student Union building on October 19, 2004 hardly seemed like the kind of event to stir up controversy.
—
So, was Epstein coming to the Berkeley campus to lecture on the Holocaust — or on her ISM experiences? This is where the controversy comes in: She was to lecture on both topics simultaneously. In fact, according to a flyer advertising her appearance which had been posted around campus, she planned to compare the Israelis’ treatment of the Palestinians with the Nazis’ treatment of the Jews.
—
Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of the evening was the silence: despite the audience being evenly divided between Epstein supporters and detractors, with members of Hillel sitting nearly shoulder-to-shoulder with members of the Muslim Students Association, and even ISM activists just a few feet from soldiers in the Israeli Defense Forces, no one said a word. Everyone politely clapped when she took the podium, and listened attentively when she spoke. There were no interruptions, no arguments or fights in the audience — an atmosphere of total civility and respect.
I support anyone’s right to speak their mind, no matter how I feel about the issue at hand. Mrs. De Witt should have a chance to hold her rally, and we should expect her to be treated with the same respect shown to Mrs. Epstein. Anything less would expose the leftists of Berkeley for the hypocrites that they are.
If you’d like to show your support for Mrs. De Witt by contacting the city of Berkeley, here is some contact information. This rally must go on, and defenders of free speech from all over the political spectrum should see to it that it does.









