Wednesday, June 29th 2005
Jumping to Conclusions
It’s always sad when random violence claims another victim:
Joe Wagner, who wanted nothing more than to be a civil rights leader, once told his father he was willing to give his life for the cause.
“Joe was a son of Ann Arbor who was an activist working for freedom, equality and peace,” said John Wagner of Ann Arbor this morning. “It’s a tragedy he’s been lost.”
Joe Wagner, 21, a 2002 graduate of Pioneer High School, was stabbed to death Saturday night at a church festival and dance in Detroit.
You try and understand how another human can be so evil, that he or she would take an innocent life.
Wagner worked for the group BAMN, or “By Any Means Necessary,” which is fighting a ballot initiative that would ban affirmative action in Michigan…
“It’s horrible,” Driver said. “He was a really great guy, and he was a great organizer and a great person. He’s going to be a real loss to the fight to win equality in this country, and build a new civil rights movement.”
My first thought: What a pity; life taken at its prime, and at least he stood for something which is rare nowadays. My second thought: Oh man, they’re going to blame Ward Connerly for this. Lo and behold, this post from a random blog [link removed, see comments]:
Read the article here about how Joe Wagner, a BAMN advocate, was killed for sticking up for what he believed in…
I remember signing a BAMN petition during one of the annual Art Fairs held in Ann Arbor downtown. I agree with some of BAMN’s POVs and their desire to see change in universities with the issue of affirmative action. If someone opposes another’s viewpoint, it should be taken in the form of debate, not guns and knives.
While I share his view that we should fight with words and not weapons, he’s really jumping to conclusions here. There is no indication that this murder was politically motivated. It just seems like yet another sad case of random violence in our inner cities. I can understand why the writer would want to place the blame on his political opponents. However, if a College Republican were murdered, I wouldn’t immediately try to place the blame on a College Democrat or Green. Such a thing would never cross my mind. As the BAMN director quoted in the article said:
“There’s no way to explain these things.”










Yeah, I do admit to jumping to conclusions, especially when I do not have enough information. However, I was extremely curious as to why the media kept on emphasizing his involvement with the organization about his murder in the news articles. I immediately deleted the article when I realized that my statements were unjustified and will be more careful with my choice of words. If you don’t mind, I’d like the reference to my blog and my statements retracted from this article as my point of view on the situation no longer applies.
Comment by AC — 6/29/2005 @ 8:39 am
I have removed the link to your blog, but I have to keep the excerpt. My point was that people jump to conclusions, and even though you have changed your opinion, you did jump to a conclusion at first. We cover BAMN on this blog, so this is an important news item to note. But though I disagree with BAMN’s politics, I do agree with you that differences should be sorted out with debate instead of violence, even though that probably wasn’t the case here.
Comment by patr — 6/29/2005 @ 5:31 pm
Thank you very much, but could you also delete my first comment too? I don’t want this post coming up if someone Google’s my name.
Comment by AC — 6/30/2005 @ 11:35 am
thanx PR–appreciate it.
Comment by AC — 6/30/2005 @ 10:02 pm